Key Takeaways: A jury awarded Aerosonic $116.9 million against Joby Aero, Inc. for breaching an NDA and misappropriating trade secrets related to air data probes. Suppliers should use NDAs that limit use and bar reverse engineering, label confidential material, and document every disclosure. Buyers that may later build in-house should limit the confidential information they receive, understand the contours of IP accompanying supply agreements, and if possible use “clean-room” procedures to separate work from the disclosed IP.
A Florida federal jury recently found that Joby Aero, Inc. should pay $116.9 million to aviation supplier Aerosonic for breaching a non-disclosure agreement (NDA) and willfully and maliciously misappropriating Aerosonic’s trade secrets. The jury awarded $68.6 million for breach of the NDA, $29.9 million for trade secret misappropriation, and $18.3 million in exemplary damages. The verdict remains subject to post-trial motions and a likely appeal.
Joby is based in Santa Cruz, California and develops all-electric, vertical take-off and landing (eVTOL) aircraft designed to operate as commercial air taxis. In September 2021, Joby and Aerosonic signed the NDA. Joby later purchased several air data probes, which are used to calculate airspeed, altitude, and other flight conditions, from Aerosonic. According to Aerosonic’s complaint, days after receiving its first probe, Joby asked to purchase the intellectual property rights to Aerosonic’s probes, but Aerosonic refused. Joby then developed its own air data probes in-house, and in March 2025 Aerosonic sued Joby for breaching the NDA and misappropriating Aerosonic’s trade secrets in developing those probes.
The jury sided with Aerosonic. It found Joby breached the California-law NDA and misappropriated 26 Aerosonic trade secrets in violation of the federal Defend Trade Secrets Act (DTSA). The jury found that the misappropriation was willful and malicious, which allowed the exemplary damages award.
This verdict shows that NDAs and trade secrets can provide valuable intellectual property protection. Companies should develop an IP protection protocol before engaging with potential business partners. The protocol should identify confidential information, document and label it as confidential, and implement reasonable measures to keep it secret. Companies should also consider drafting NDAs with express limits on the use of confidential information and restrictions on reverse engineering. As confidential information is shared, companies should document what was shared, when, with whom, and under which agreement.
Companies that buy parts from suppliers but may someday want to build those parts in-house should review NDAs closely before entering them. If possible, they should limit the supplier’s confidential disclosures to what the company actually needs, and consider negotiating express terms for independently developed technology. Buyers should also have counsel advise on the contours of the IP that has been disclosed or licensed in the deal, so that any independent work can steer clear of such IP. Finally, before beginning in-house development, the company should consider setting up a “clean room” for such work. This separates independent development from the knowledge gained via the prior deal. One example setup is staffing the project with engineers who have not seen the supplier’s confidential materials, restricting access to those materials, and documenting the independent design work.