Key Takeaway: Effective November 16, 2026, the Patent Trial and Appeal Board will again decide on the merits whether to institute inter partes review and post-grant review proceedings, while the USPTO Director will continue deciding discretionary denial. Going forward, petitioners must explain unpatentability grounds in detail and should consider challenging only the claims they can best support, while patent owners can defeat institution with a reasonable, well-supported argument against a substantial majority of the challenged claims.
On November 10, 2026, U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) Director John Squires issued a memorandum announcing that, effective November 16, 2026, the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) will resume making merits-based decisions on whether to institute inter partes reviews (IPRs) and post-grant reviews (PGRs). The Director will continue to decide whether to deny IPR and PGR petitions on discretionary grounds such as the age of the challenged patent or the stage of co-pending litigation asserting the challenged patent. If the Director does not deny a petition on discretionary grounds, he will refer the petition to a Board panel to decide whether to institute on the merits.
Five Key Changes and Guidelines for PTAB Institution Decisions
The Director also announced procedural changes and guidance that may affect the outcome of institution decisions and the conduct of IPRs and PGRs on the merits:
1. A Different PTAB Panel Conducts Instituted IPR and PGR Trials and Issues the Final Written Decision on Patentability
The new procedure of assigning a different panel to conduct instituted IPRs and PGRs is likely designed to assuage patent-owner concerns that the earlier procedure (the same Board panel both instituting and conducting IPR and PGR trials) favored petitioners. The memo refers to one such concern, the “unfounded perception of self-interest” of a Board panel in instituting a trial that it then conducts. Another patent-owner concern was that panels that instituted a trial would likely be predisposed to issue a final written decision finding the challenged claims unpatentable. The new procedure may modestly increase the percentage of final written decisions that find the challenged claims patentable after institution.
2. The Board Issues Brief, Merits-based Institution Decisions
In a departure from Director Squires’s general practice of issuing summary institution notices for many merits decisions, the memo indicates that the Board’s merits-based institution decisions will briefly set forth enough information for at least one claim to show that the petitioner met the institution standard. Institution decisions likely will not address every ground or argument. The memo identifies two short decisions (of four and eight pages) as examples for the Board to use. The Director may still issue summary notices of discretionary denials or referrals to the Board.
3. The Board Denies Institution When the Petitioner Fails to Meet the Institution Standard for a Substantial Majority of the Challenged Claims
Prior USPTO guidance and informative Board decisions in the wake of the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2018 SAS decision provided that the Board may discretionarily deny an entire IPR or PGR petition that fails to meet the institution standard for a substantial majority of the challenged claims. By dictating that “the PTAB will deny institution” in such circumstances, the memo elevates that basis for discretionary denial into binding Director guidance to be applied by the Board.
4. A Reasonable, Well-supported Argument Against a Substantial Majority of the Challenged Claims Defeats Institution
The new binding guidance described above does not, by itself, appear to significantly shift the balance against institution in most cases. However, the memo also indicates that the Board will deny institution when the patent owner (or the Board) raises a reasonable argument, well-supported with reliable, credible evidence, that the petitioner does not meet the institution standard for a substantial majority of the challenged claims. That guidance appears to shift the balance against institution in cases where the patent owner or Board raises a patentability argument that is reasonable and well-supported but that ultimately would not prevail in a full trial.
5. The Board Strictly Enforces the Requirement That Petitions Explain Unpatentability Grounds in Detail
The memo reaffirms current practice that the petition must point out and explain, limitation-by-limitation, how the prior art discloses or renders obvious each limitation of each challenged claim.
Strategic Implications for Patent Owners and Petitioners
Director Squires’s new guidance will influence patent owner and petitioner IPR and PGR strategies in several ways, including:
- Discretionary Denial Remains Unchanged. Discretionary considerations, such as the age of challenged patents (settled expectations) and the stage of litigation, will likely continue to deter potential petitioners from filing IPRs in many cases where the patents have been in force for at least six years or a district court or U.S. International Trade Commission (ITC) trial is likely to occur before the Board would issue a final written decision. Potential petitioners should carefully consider all circumstances in deciding whether an IPR or PGR, an ex parte reexamination, or a district court or ITC validity challenge is the best vehicle for challenging a patent. Patent owners will continue to request discretionary denial in most cases.
- Petitioners and Patent Owners Should Present Strong, Well-Developed Grounds at Institution. As always, petitioners should present a detailed, limitation-by-limitation explanation of where the prior art discloses each claim limitation. In addition, when petitioners have strong unpatentability arguments for only a few of the claims of a patent, they should consider challenging only those claims and not challenging claims for which they have weaker unpatentability arguments. Conversely, the reasonable, well-supported argument standard provides additional incentive for patent owners to make their strongest patentability arguments that are applicable to most of the claims at the preliminary stage, rather than saving them for later.
- Post-institution Flexibility Increases for Patent Owners and Petitioners. Historically, the Board provided lengthy institution decisions on the merits that, while not binding, provided significant guidance about the Board’s initial thinking that strongly influenced the parties’ post-institution strategies. Now that a Board panel will issue a brief institution decision and likely will not address all issues, and a different panel will be assigned post-institution, the parties will have more flexibility to develop their post-institution strategies.