In a recent IAM article, Knobbe Martens partner Ted Cannon discussed how the Federal Circuit’s precedential decision in In re Netlist affects motivation-to-combine arguments in patent obviousness challenges before the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB).
In its decision, the Federal Circuit reiterated that the motivation-to-combine inquiry focuses on whether a skilled artisan would have been motivated to combine prior-art references to achieve the claimed invention. The ruling emphasizes that arguments that a combination would undermine the purpose of the prior art are relevant to defeat obviousness only in limited circumstances.
Cannon, who chairs the firm’s PTAB Trials practice, identified consumer electronics as one industry that could be impacted by the ruling, where diverse consumer preferences can create numerous reasons to combine elements. He recommended that patent challengers “expressly identify one or more motivations to combine” that are separate from any prior-art purpose that would be lost in the combination, and to support them with compelling evidence that a skilled artisan would still have made the combination.
For patent owners, Cannon explained that showing a combination would make a reference inoperable is often not enough. Instead, he suggested that patent owners evaluate other arguments based on the case facts, such as whether the combination would deliver the claimed benefits, whether its disadvantages outweigh them, and whether the prior art teaches away or is non-analogous.
Read Cannon’s full comments in the article, “Federal Circuit Narrows Patent Owners’ Defense to Obviousness Attacks” on IAM [subscription required].